Go Back   PrintPlanet.com

View Single Post
  #3 (permalink)  
Old 07-06-2009, 01:14 PM
John Clifford John Clifford is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 75
Default

Type in photoshop is almost always problematic.

The problem is that Photoshop is a RASTER format. Text gets rasterized once it's taken out of native Photoshop. As noted in the previous reply, you can maintain vectors by saving as a Photoshop PDF, but I suspect that it was an eps, tiff, or other format that was brought into Quark. The saving as a tiff or eps rasterizes the Photoshop image at the resolution designated for the image (300ppi). Even bringing native psd files into Quark does not maintain rasters (I believe), although InDesign may.

That means that the text will be 300dpi when it's plated whereas if it were vectored text (Illustrator, InDesign, Quark, PDF, etc.) it would be rasterized at 2400+ dpi when it's plated. Images (which is a definition of a photoshop file) are usually screened, so 300 ppi/dpi is optimal, but text should not have a screen value so vectored is always better.

My recommendation is that images not have text and that the text be added in the Quark file. If that's impractical, then the image (photoshop) should be placed into Illustrator and text added there.

I worked as prepress manager for a period at a printer whose niche market was photographers and we had to deal with the problem that they ONLY had photoshop and only knew how to use photoshop. In those days there was no way of maintaining vectors in PS so it was always a hassle of dealing with the questions of "why does my type look so sh***y!"

Last edited by John Clifford; 07-06-2009 at 01:17 PM.
Reply With Quote
 
Sponsors
Job Postings from JobsTheyWant
Solutions Finishing and Controls Engineer at Hewlett Packard in Corvallis, OR
Digital Indigo Press Operator at O'Neil Data Systems in Los Angeles, CA
Managed Print Services Sales Executive at Meredith Corporation in Des Moines, Iowa
Key Accounts Technical Color Mgmt Specialist at GMG Americas in Hingham, MA
Account Manager - Commercial Sales at NewPage Corporation in Southeast ( Charlotte, Atlanta, Jacksonville )
Account Manager-Commercial Sales at NewPage Corporation in Northeast (New York, Baltimore, Washington)
Account Manager Commercial Sales at NewPage Corporation in Midwest (Chicago,Dallas,Kansas City, Minneapolis
Services Business Development Manager at Electronics for Imaging in Foster City
WhatTheyThink.com Latest Industry News
Transcontinental continues profits on strong Q1
X-Rite shows profits in Q4, first since 2007
Indigo division posts record page volumes
Census counts on GPO
NewPage to purchase Domtar coated groundwood product lines
Brown Printing receives web offset association award
Peer Groups: Leading by Example
EskoArtwork launches new digital finishing solution
Presstek to expand dimension Pro CTP portfolio at IPEX
Attendance surges at INTERQUEST digital book printing forum


Print CEO
Links, information, analysis and commentary from various industry resources.

WhatTheyThink's Speakers Bureau
Need a speaker for your open house, conference, or special event?

WhatTheyThink's Consulting Services
Business Strategy, Workflow Integration, Sales & Marketing, Custom Research