Standard Finishing


No announcement yet.

A Hurdle to High Speed Inkjet Supremacy Writ Small


  • A Hurdle to High Speed Inkjet Supremacy Writ Small

    The ascendancy of production inkjet may be written in disappearing ink…or not.

    by Sean O'Leary
    There is a speed bump dogging the supremacy of inkjet technology like trouble dogs River City. We’re talking about de-inking. That is to say, “pulp laundering”, the key component of the recycling process in which ink residue is washed and filtered out of incoming paper stock. The problem is that aqueous inkjet formulations are difficult to completely remove from paper pulp and that can mess up the whole process.

    Technically speaking, the reason for this is as follows: “hydrophilic pigments and soluble dyes do not agglomerate to suitable particle size for the dominant separation method, i.e. flotation, but dissolve or form too small pieces which remain in the liquid phase or adhere on the fiber surface causing deteriorated brightness.”

    That excerpt is from a 2012 patent application for a deinking method. It is basically saying the dye particle sizes are too small to filter or float. Dye inks are soluble and don’t latch onto air bubbles and float to the surface of a de-inking tank. A fairly small percentage of inkjet-printed stock – from 5 to 10% from what I read - can contaminate an entire batch of mixed papers.

    Even though it is decidedly unsexy compared to the sleek inkjet platforms you’ll be seeing at drupa, de-inking is a technically challenging undertaking. It has taken a lot of time, expense and infrastructure to develop today’s reliable deinking and recycling methods. It has also required a lot of collaboration among industry silos with a history of passive-aggressive relationships. Not surprisingly, the recycling processes in use today have been optimized for efficient deinking of offset ink formulations.

    There is of course some irony involved with the fact that aqueous inks – understood to be a “green” technology – represent an impediment to the recycling of paper. Yet there it is.

    This year, as we head into drupa 2016, there is every reason to believe that de-inkability has begun to get the attention it deserves. In no small part, that is thanks to INGEDE.

    INGEDE Indeed
    Yes, there is a de-Inking trade association: the International Association of the Deinking Industry (INGEDE). Originally founded in 1989 by European paper manufacturers, one of INGEDE’s most important missions in the twenty-first century has been to drag the parties involved in inkjet de-inking issues to the table. The association’s efforts eventually resulted in the formation of Digital Print Deinking Alliance (DPDA), which is currently comprised of Canon, HP, Kodak,Oce´and Ricoh.

    Human nature being what it is, the digital de-inking challenge resulted in robust discussions between inkjet printer manufacturers and the paper industry as to how serious the deinking situation was. Ultimately it came down to who was going to devote the resources to fixing the problem.

    INGEGE and DPDA didn’t see eye to eye at first. When INGEDE developed the Method 11 deinking standard, DPDA pushed back with fixes that INGEDE deemed inadequate. You read between the lines in the press releases, it isn’t a stretch to conclude that sometimes the discussions were very robust.

    But this is not easy.

    The de-ink fix involves collaboration among powerful global players who are protecting trade secrets and are less enthusiastic about the whole de-inking thing than developing new printers. On the other side paper companies historically have a chip on their shoulders. Furthermore, any testing has by necessity to be system based: printing platform, ink formulation and paper stock.

    Manufacturers who intend to play in the production speed inkjet market of the future understand they have to deal with this issue. Longer print runs probably mean larger customers, and larger customers probably mean more sensitivity to sustainability issues. Although progress toward a greener world moves by fits and starts, the global circular economy can be expected to expand as a fundamental unpinning of all commercial enterprises. It is therefore reasonable to expect the role of paper recycling to evolve as well.

    After a slow start, good things began to happen in the inkjet de-inking world. In 2014, INGEDE delivered what amounted to their first de-inkability seal of approval for a web-fed aqueous system (KBA Rotajet). Likewise, London’s University of the Arts, Western Michigan University and other academic institutions are working with manufacturers on developing and evaluating de-inking technology. FOGRA began publishing an inkjet de-inking approval two years ago.

    We have good reason to expect game changing production inkjet platforms to be unveiled on the drupa ’16 show floor. We will hear about leaps in production speed, solid coverage density, scalability, resolution, reliability and affordability. That is all invigorating, but if you find yourself involved in a floor demonstration and need a change of pace, try asking the sales person about the system’s de-inkability characteristics.

    Let us know what they say.
      Posting comments is disabled.



    Latest Articles


    • The Space Between: RISO Nails the “Business InkJet” Niche
      by MyWildIrishProse
      by Sean O’Leary

      The transition from electrostatic/toner printers to inkjet printing continues apace, with few observers doubting that inkjet platforms will prevail in the long term. The latest generation of production inkjet presses from Xerox, KM, and Ricoh are faster than toner-based (EP) machines and generally cost less per page for the same job. As for the color accuracy question, once the accountants and customers take a good look at total benefits, it turns out that inkjet color...
      04-17-2019, 10:02 PM
    • Print MIS: Can You Follow the Money?
      by noelward
      By Noel Ward, Editor@Large

      In the average week (as if there is such a thing!) how many different jobs and projects are on your plate? If yours is like many shops these days, your work in process may span offset, digital, and large format work, along with direct mail, data management, maybe some fulfillment, and even mobile communications. The deadlines are relentless, the pressure builds and the frustration mounts, at least some of the time. And then your lead sales guy comes in with...
      03-24-2019, 06:25 PM
    • The Move to Inkjet
      by noelward
      By Noel Ward, Editor@Large

      For the past few years one of the questions I’ve gotten from print providers running toner presses is along the lines of, “How much volume should I have before I move to inkjet?” It’s an excellent query and it shows that people are thinking.

      Then there are the ones who call, bemoaning their lack of foresight, saying “I bought this UltraJet C6000 and it’s costing me a fortune. What can I do?”

      To be clear, there are many...
      03-21-2019, 06:11 PM
    • A Fast Track for File Prep
      by noelward
      By Noel Ward, Editor@Large

      Does any of this sound familiar?

      A few times each week a customer shows up or sends in a file that needs a lot of love. It’s usually work they don’t want to do (or can’t do) themselves and involves making sure a stack of pages will be professionally printed. Those pages may be a mix of original files, scans from who knows where, and a cover that needs to be updated, along with the titling on the spine. Then there are colors that need to...
      02-28-2019, 02:43 PM
    • How CHILI’S New Illustrator® Feature Plugs Into An Increasingly Automated Future
      by MyWildIrishProse
      By Sean O'Leary

      As 2019 kicks off, CHILI publish will begin rolling out a new Illustrator Plug-in for its Universal Graphics Engine platform. That news is bigger than it sounds at first.

      The “native AI document conversion utility” is particularly targeted to the packaging and label industries, which, due to the greater complexity of their graphics (and the incorporation of large numbers of vector components), have historically favored the Adobe Illustrator®...
      02-01-2019, 10:26 AM
    • Why Ever Would You Want to Automate?
      by noelward
      by Noel Ward, Editor@Large

      Why ever would you want to automate your operation? After all, it seems far too complex, costs money, involves a lot of your people, will absorb significant time, and you figure you probably don’t need it. And then you run out of excuses.

      I used to work with a guy who had some 20-odd years in printing and packaging behind him. He insisted that every shop he went into had a superbly lean and extremely efficient workflow and spectacular MIS. He...
      01-09-2019, 02:50 PM