Standard Finishing
4Over

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

PDF Transparency/Layers

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • PDF Transparency/Layers

    I do the input of jobs in a print on demand dept. I continually have problems with transparency and/or layer issues, ie, text (many time with a drop shadow) knocking out the background.

    I am printing from a Fiery RIP to a Konica-Minolta 6500.

    I have tried all kinds of settings in Acrobat (7&8) and PitStop (7.2). I have not found a solution with those programs.
    The only way to solve the problem is open the PDF in Photoshop and flatten it and then save it back to a PDF.

    Are there settings that I can use in Acrobat/PitStop to resolve this?
    Do I need to have the designers use different settings when creating the PDFs? They use the export to pdf features which I have always had trouble with but I can't get them to change their ways.

    Suggestions/answers...anything.

    Dov, I know if anyone has the answer it's you. I've been a fan for many years.

    Thanks in advance,
    Gerry

  • #2
    Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

    I'm no Dov Issacs, but when I print to our Fiery and the file uses transparency I usually check the
    Simulate Overprint box in the print dialog. Sometimes this'll help. Our Fiery is a dog when it comes
    to flattening artwork. Another thing I do is change the compatibility to Acrobat 4, or Print To File first.
    Not really the text book way to go about it, but one of these will generally do the trick.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

      Thomas is right...
      If you go to adobe's www. do a search for Trans. They have good reads.
      I have the same issues with Trans. with our Fiery Rip on a c500. as well as our HP Designjet 5500ps.
      Some rips cant handle complex stuff. (Come on "Adobe Print Engine")

      You can go to the advanced settings and click "print as file" this will do what photoshop does. But, your color may be off. This is a quick on the fly trick.

      What Thomas said about "print to file" is correct. I've found that this is the best method for flattening and keeping vectors.

      If you have Indy...I pull PDF into Indy and export as EPS. In your eps settings you can control Trans flattening.
      The cool thing is postscript cant hold Trans....so it must flatten. So Adobe says. But, I still have some issues from time to time on complex stuff.
      But, for the most part export as EPS and .ps files then distill have been a BIG Help.

      Best of Luck...Trans can be a pain.
      Let us know...

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

        BTW...Beware of Quack 7 files.
        We export eps out of Quack too.
        We had some issues the other week where the drop shadow was in the PDF (made from Quack).
        But, when pullend into Indy and printed. It dropped out.

        Export as EPS saved the day...

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

          I *am* Dov Isaacs and my experience with Fiery RIPs and PDF files is that the best way to print to such RIPs is by printing PostScript to them from Acrobat 8.x Pro. Use the "high resolution" flattening parameters. In the Acrobat 8.x Pro "Advanced" print dialog, use the +U.S. Web Coated (SWOP) v2+ color settings. Do +not+ use the default +Printer / PostScript Color Management+ setting. And do +not+ send any spot colors to the RIP; let Acrobat change them to process (preferably, in your layout program, you use LaB alternates instead of CMYK).

          On the RIP side, set the Fiery to simulate SWOP CMYK. Turn off all hackery such as modifications to overprint based on object type. That stuff just doesn't work with flattened transparency.

          Note, if SWOP is not your standard CMYK print condition, choose the corresponding CMYK in Acrobat's print dialog +and+ in the Fiery device settings - make sure that they match.

          - Dov

          PS: I am the Adobe "spiritual venture capitalist" behind the Adobe PDF Print Engine!

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

            Thanks to all who replied.

            I have used all of those solutions to some extent on various jobs. Sometimes they work, sometimes I have to try another of the work-arounds.

            PrepressDog mentions importing into InDesign and exporting as EPS. This brings up the question about how to create a PDF from native programs. Export or print to PDF? I have always had better results printing to PDF or .ps and then distilling. Comments?

            As far as Quack 7 goes, our whole prepress dept. hates to see these files from customers. Especially when the customer has used all the new "features". Then again, I just plain hate Quack.

            I have just upgraded to Acro 8 and it has solved a lot of the problems. EFI has not upgraded and so I was forced to use v7 to take advantage of the tools in Command Workstation. Catch 22 with the Fiery RIP, they recommend using v7 but trans., etc. are problematic so you have to use v8 to get good results but it doesn't interface with their tools. Fiery RIPs are another thing that I hate. I have never met one that worked well. But, from what I hear from our Prepress dept. that uses a Rampage RIP it's problematic also.

            I use all the settings you have recommended Dov. It's good to know I'm on the right track. I do wonder about using LaB color settings. In other words, I know nothing about that color standard. And I know I'd be spitting in the wind trying to get Prepress to use it, they are all used to creating jobs for press so I am constantly having them re-output their files for the Fiery/c6500.

            Thanks again to everyone,
            Gerry

            The Struggle Continues...

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

              > {quote:title=gerrye wrote:}{quote}
              > PrepressDog mentions importing into InDesign and exporting as EPS. This brings up the question about how to create a PDF from native programs. Export or print to PDF? I have always had better results printing to PDF or .ps and then distilling. Comments?
              >
              > I use all the settings you have recommended Dov. It's good to know I'm on the right track. I do wonder about using LaB color settings. In other words, I know nothing about that color standard. And I know I'd be spitting in the wind trying to get Prepress to use it, they are all used to creating jobs for press so I am constantly having them re-output their files for the Fiery/c6500.

              Some shops won't accept PDF's that weren't created by Distiller. For whatever reason files exported to or saved as PDF have a much greater tendency to be problematic.

              As to your question about usint L*a*b* - CIELab would require some kind of processing to get into the color space of your output device.

              rich

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

                PrepressDog,

                Did you ever let Quark make the PostScript and get Distiller to make the PDF (instead of letting Quark make the PDF)? Confirmation (besides myself) that this is a great workaround for many people (instead of printing from Quark 7 or letting Quark make the PDF) and being able to bypass/circumvent problems (before they happen) would speak volumes I'm sure to everyone here. This is my workflow for Quark 7 and the only tried and true way I have been able to get Quark 7 jobs out while keeping the small amount of sanity I have left.

                Don

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

                  I'm not sure what the designers do. I know they don't like Quack 7 files. I don't think they use it unless forced to because a customer used it.

                  I hardly ever get native files and would never get Quack. Prepress/Designers (P/D) are mac and I'm PC, so there are too many issues especially fonts.

                  As far as outputting to .ps and then distilling, I'm going to suggest that we start doing that. Even have customers print to .ps. I'm also thinking about doing all the distilling myself. P/D don't know anything hardly about PDF except for the manager.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

                    Gerry said:
                    PrepressDog mentions importing into InDesign and exporting as EPS. This brings up the question about how to create a PDF from native programs. Export or print to PDF? I have always had better results printing to PDF or .ps and then distilling. Comments?

                    Printing to PDF does not use Adobe Distiller which may cause problems. We save it as a postscript file then to distiller. I have found less problems doing this way than exporting directly to Distiller. Just my 2 cents.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

                      I don't know where you got that information...but printing to the Adobe
                      PDF Printer is the EXACT SAME THING as printing to a Postscript file and
                      then dropping that on Distiller with the JobOption chosen. In fact,
                      that's what the printer is doing behind the scenes!

                      On the other issue, I continue to stand on the position that creation
                      via Export (or Save As) from an application is the BEST way to create a
                      PDF, because it will give you the highest fidelity of data.

                      Leonard

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

                        I'd have to say that exporting to PS then distilling seems to work much better than exporting to PDF directly. I get fewer issues brought up by my printers, and flattening is usually (I say *usually*) not an issue.

                        PrepressDog, you might also want to instruct the designers to make sure any ID files have separate text layers on top of any vector/image and effects layers. As I understand it, when ID flattens on export, it rasterizes layers separately, then merges them. If text and effect (like the ever-popular drop shadow) are rasterized in the same layer, the text can become very muddy. In some cases, the effect completely disappears, which could be the cause of the problem you mentioned earlier.

                        I'm not sure if the same problem exists in Quark, but it's worth investigating. Your designers may already know to do this, but just thought I'd mention it.

                        Best of luck!
                        -
                        Jack Cole

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

                          > I'd have to say that exporting to PS then distilling seems to work much better than exporting to PDF directly. I get fewer issues brought up by my printers, and flattening is usually (I say *usually*) not an issue.

                          Could you give some specific examples of problems encountered with PDFs created via export?

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

                            Leonard wrote:
                            I don't know where you got that information...but printing to the Adobe
                            PDF Printer is the EXACT SAME THING as printing to a Postscript file and
                            then dropping that on Distiller with the JobOption chosen. In fact,
                            that's what the printer is doing behind the scenes!

                            On the other issue, I continue to stand on the position that creation
                            via Export (or Save As) from an application is the BEST way to create a
                            PDF, because it will give you the highest fidelity of data.

                            Dov, can we get your opinion on this?

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: PDF Transparency/Layers

                              One ID file had a habit of crashing the RIP whenever I used ID's Export-->PDF, but seemed to go through fine when I exported as a PS then used Distiller with identical output settings. The printer suggested the Distiller route, and it worked fine. There was nothing extraordinary about the file, although it did have a number of large EPSs (linked, not embedded) in it.

                              I'm not sure why there'd be any difference, but since this happened, I've been using the Distiller route on anything destined for press, and save the Export-->PDF for rendering for screen.

                              Unrelated to the print process, but... I noticed that with Acrobat 7/ID(CS2), sometimes I'd get thin white lines around placed objects in my PDFs exported directly. I've since read that this was a problem Adobe fixed in Acro8, but it usually disappears whenever I use Export-->PS-->Distiller. There are some [other workarounds for it as well|http://www.layersmagazine.com/forum/...ead.php?t=823] - the print/design communities are usually a huge help when these oddities show up.

                              Cheers,
                              -
                              Jack Cole

                              Comment

                              UltimateDuploSmartsoft (Presswise)Standard FinishingKBA4Over
                              UltimateDuploStandard FinishingKBAKBA GTIChili publish4Over

                              What's Going On

                              Collapse

                              There are currently 4729 users online. 104 members and 4625 guests.

                              Most users ever online was 6,151 at 11:36 AM on 11-17-2017.

                              Working...
                              X