I think I figured it out. The head suckers were set, with the set screw on the bar, angled a little too far forward (away from the press). This changed the timing of the sheet to the feed rollers slightly. The feed rollers were also a little loose (compared to the timing). Fixing this allowed me to use the early/late sheet adjustment on the non op side. I get a perfect straight line in the sheet trend indicator. The head stop timing is about 8 degrees off, but that could be operator error running at crawl speed.