I've just noticed that Adobe has updated the web page at
https://helpx.adobe.com/creative-cloud/adobe-color.html which has been updated to the following “new” text:
Changes to the Pantone Color Libraries
Pantone Matches are no longer supported in Adobe Color. Pantone color libraries currently preloaded in Adobe Photoshop, Illustrator, and InDesign, will be phased out starting August 31, 2022 (with the exception of PANTONE+ CMYK Coated, PANTONE+ CMYK Uncoated, PANTONE+ Metallic Coated). Pantone is supporting their most up-to-date color libraries exclusively through the Pantone Connect plug-in available
here. Adobe and Pantone have been working together to support your color needs and additional information and tutorials will be available shortly.
What exactly does this mean?
Pantone matches not being supported in
Adobe Color is somewhat irrelevant from the point of view that the
Adobe Color service (as opposed to the applications' own support for color) never really supported ICC Color Management. RGB and CMYK values are provided, but exactly
which RGB and
which CMYK. That's critically important unless you don't really care about rendering for anything other than for cheap computer and telephone screens and certainly not for print! At best, you can get LAB values out of Adobe Color and use more conventional tools to ascertain whether the color(s) are really appropriate for you and what they really translate to in the real world.
Except for Acrobat, the March 2022 deadline for impact on Photoshop, Illustrator, and InDesign has apparently slipped to August 2022. Complaints from the “real world” users of Adobe products must have had some impact.
The real got'cha seems to be the wording “with the exception of PANTONE+ CMYK Coated, PANTONE+ CMYK Uncoated, PANTONE+ Metallic Coated.” In the case of both the PANTONE+ CMYK definitions sets, you don't get support for LAB colors at all, just some generic (SWOP perhaps?) CMYK definitions.
Yet more of this “additional information and tutorials will be available shortly” craziness. One thing that supposedly is true is that
existing content with embedded Pantone color definitions won't be lost. The problem is what happens if you want to replace one Pantone color currently being used with another one that isn't already in your document's existing swatches. Forgetting about the onerous licensing costs to access the full Pantone libraries, existing user satisfaction (read the reviews) with the Pantone Connect plug-ins (see
Pantone Connect) is anything other than stellar. (The plug-in isn't free if you want/need the full definitions!)
Stay tuned for more craziness!
- Dov